| Posted: 17 October 2005 at 3:59pm | IP Logged
|
|
|
GlenW wrote:
|
ok - where in the study did it say nobody committed suicide while taking placebo?
|
|
|
On Strattera's manufacturer's (Eli Lilly) own site? Thats the first place I looked to check it out.
http://newsroom.lilly.com/ReleaseDetail.cfm?ReleaseID=175142
"...In conjunction with a request from the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA), Lilly submitted to regulatory agencies an analysis of adverse event data from its Strattera clinical trials database that identified a small but statistically significant increased risk of suicidal thoughts among Strattera-treated children and adolescents (5 cases out of 1357 patients or 0.4 percent vs. 0 cases out of 851 patients taking placebo)..."
Balanced may not post links to what he says, but he does have the facts straight as far as I can see.
Please note its .04, not .004 which I realise may well have been a typo or innocent miscalculation in your earlier post, but there's a rather large difference - so needs attention.
In reply to CSMommy
["You find me a group of 1000 that does not have 4 people with suicidel thinking."]
851 (study participants that were on placebo) is more than half of the Strattera-treated children. So if its difficult to believe that anyone would find a group of 1,000 that does not have 4 suicidal people in it, particularly bearing in mind that these are children and adolescents with ADHD rather than any group of 1000, then the placebo looks rather promising as a future treatment.
Even without an expectation that 4 in any group of 1,000 people are going to be suicidal and going only on the study figures:
If 5 out of 1357 children experienced suicidality on Strattera, then between 2 and 3 children at least out of 851 should have experienced suicidality on placebo. In fact, if Strattera is an effective medication, then presumably those going UNmedicated should have experienced suicidality at an even higher rate than the group being medicated.
Presumably then, the placebo and its inactive components are effective in preventing suicidality (and should be used as treatment) or Strattera causes suicidality.
As far as I can make out. ?
Edited by curus on 17 October 2005 at 4:21pm
|