Need Advice on Disciplining Child | ADHD Information

Share
I would not take away the birthday present, but make him help replace the snare. ADHD kids do not deal well with this that type of punishment(long term) and it is better if quick and to the point. My ds loses all privledges for 1 day. This was from the therapist. More rewarding less punishment. and I agree with the others How old is he?

Hi, I am also wondering--how old is your son? That is important info.

As a teacher and parent, I am always pleased when parents hold children accountable for their actions.  Kudos to you.

I like what you and the above poster wrote about the possible consequences with the exception that I would encourage you  to consider making  his Birthday/birthday present totally separate from the consequences. A birthday comes once a year. It's VERY special. It's supposed to celebrate your child's life and the year ahead.  You are already doing "natural consequences" with the repairs/replacement of the drum AND the consequences of  having house restrictions that sound fair and smart from what you wrote.

Good luck!

Again how old is the child?  The idea of him repairing the damage in any way that is age appropriate is a good one but it must be done in love... This is a way for you to help him feel better.  It sounds like this.  I know you feel terrible about the drum and I am sorry I did not do a better job of keeping you safe from trouble.  Lets you and I try to make this better....

It just may be that being at the home of a friend with out you there is too much for him...  Too many things to get into and no safe haven from his implusiveness...

I would not take away his birthday... One thing has nothing to do with the other...  do you celebrate his birth?  If finances are tight you may not be able to afford an Ipod once you replace the drum.  (Look for one on E-bay)  But that is just life and not a punishment.   Those are the real consequences life throws at us not the made up ones so many parents use...

Okay, so here the story: My son last night at a home of a family friends got into some serious mischief, which is really unusual for him. Well past meds in his system time, he was supposed to watching a move. Apparently, he grew bored and found a cosmetics bag of one of her girls'. He sprayed perfume all over the place, but worse, put nail polish all over a snare drum and poked a pole in its skin.

Of course, he didn't admit to doing it without much prodding. We offered to replace the snare drum, which will cost around 150 (unless we can just fix the skin and then it will be around 50), and grounded him for 2 weeks minimum. He is allowed to play music, read, or do workbooks. I've also told him he can ride bike and jump on the trampoline just to burn off the excess energy. His birthday is coming up and in my fit of anger and embarrassment I told him that he had just "spent" his birthday gift. We were going to get him an ipod.

My question to the team is this: Did we go to far? Would you take away his birthday gift? He's young so obviously can't earn the money through a job, or even working for us (he does plently of chores just as member of our family for free). And, while I understand that his impulsiveness got the best of him, I can't allow him to use his ADHD as an excuse for misbehavior because the world won't...

Your thoughts?

How old is your son?   My inclination would be to have him come up with a way to repair/replace what was ruined.    He should be the one the come up with the plan and then follow through on it.   Here are a few things that come to mind.

Can he work for your friends that owned the drums?   Is there extra stuff he can do around the house for you guys?    Does he have any games/toys/etc that he could try to sell on craigslist?   Maybe you could give him the money you were going to spend on his present and let him us it to pay for the drum and whatever is left, he could something smaller.Instead of a specific dollar amount that he has to earn, you do do something like he has to put in 10 hours of working.

< =text/>_popupControl(); I wouldn't take the birthday gift away, I'd make him "earn" the money some other way. I agree that the long-term consequence of the loss of the gift might be too much.

Then, after he has dealt with the grounding and the consequence, I would think about pre-emptive measures I could take next time to keep this from happening. Could he get a booster dose only when your family has a night event planned? Does he have a DS or something else that holds his interest in case the event just doesn't? Did I state my expectations clearly enough for him and does he know to come and tell me if he's bored? Lastly, I'd let him know that we could pull the plug on the event if he truly feels like he can't control his behavior. Depending on how old your son is, that feeling of controlling the situation might be enough to help him make it through the evening.